Tips for your first people management role as a tax professional
Stepping into your first people management role as a tax professional is both an exciting milestone and a significant shift in responsibility. For years, your success may have been defined by technical accuracy, client delivery, and your ability to navigate complex legislation. Now you are expected to guide others through that complexity, nurture their growth, and ensure the team functions effectively. The transition requires new skills, new mindsets, and a willingness to learn just as much about people as you have about tax. Here are practical, grounded tips to help you succeed.
Recognise that your role has fundamentally changed
One of the biggest challenges for new managers is understanding that technical excellence and management excellence are not the same thing. You were promoted because you are good at your job, but you will succeed as a manager only if you shift from doing the work to enabling others to do it.
This means embracing activities that might not have been part of your remit before: coaching, giving feedback, setting expectations, and having difficult conversations. In tax, where deadlines and accuracy are non-negotiable, it can be tempting to continue doing tasks yourself because it feels quicker or safer. However, if you fall into that pattern, you miss opportunities to develop your team and you risk burning yourself out.
Action to take in week 1:
Goal: Stop being the “best doer”, become the “enabler.”
- Write down your new responsibilities e.g. coaching, feedback, prioritisation, communication
- Identify tasks you should no longer personally own
- Block 20–30% of your calendar for people management
- When tempted to “just do it myself”, pause and ask: is this a development opportunity?
- Track how much time you spend doing vs enabling, and aim for a gradual shift
Build trust early and intentionally
Trust is the foundation of effective management, especially in a technical profession like tax where the stakes are high. New managers sometimes assume trust will develop naturally over time, but it must be built deliberately.
Start by getting to know your team members as people. Understand where they are in their careers, what motivates them, and where they feel most and least confident. Demonstrate reliability by following through on commitments and being consistent in your communication. Make yourself approachable by being present and attentive, whether in person or online.
The more your team trusts you, the more willing they will be to raise issues early, before they turn into missed deadlines or compliance risks.
Action to take in weeks 1-2
Goal: become approachable and reliable quickly
Schedule a 1-to-1 with every team member and ask:
- Career goals
- Strengths and confidence areas
- Stress points
- Preferred communication style
- How they like feedback
Then:
- Career goals
- Strengths and confidence areas
- Stress points
- Preferred communication style
- How they like feedback
Shift from giving answers to asking questions
As a technical expert, you may be used to being the person others come to for solutions. As a manager, your challenge is to encourage independent thinking while still ensuring quality.
When someone asks you a technical question, resist the urge to provide the answer immediately. Instead, try asking:
- “What options have you already considered?”
- “What does the guidance suggest?”
- “If you had to make a recommendation, what would it be?”
Action to take: coach instead of answer
Goal: grow independent thinkers
When asked a question, don’t answer immediately. Use the rule:
Ask three before you tell one
- “What options have you considered?”
- “What does the guidance say?”
- “What would you recommend?”
Only then:
Confirm or refine their conclusion. You are training judgement, not giving solutions.
Give feedback that genuinely helps people grow
Feedback is one of the most powerful tools you have as a manager, but it must be delivered thoughtfully. In tax, accuracy, clarity, and timeliness are critical. People need to know not only what needs improvement but how to improve it.
Effective feedback is:
- Specific – Avoid vague comments like “be more proactive.” Explain exactly what behaviour you observed and what you’d like to see instead
- Timely – Don’t wait for formal reviews. Provide feedback as close to the moment as possible, while it’s still relevant
- Balanced – Highlight strengths as well as areas for improvement. This builds confidence and reinforces what to keep doing
Remember that feedback should feel like a conversation, not a judgement. Invite your team member to reflect on the situation and share their own perspective. This increases commitment to change and strengthens your working relationship.
Action to take: give effective and ongoing feedback
Goal: make improvement predictable
After reviewing work:
- Give feedback within 24–48 hours
- Be specific
- Explain impacts e.g. risk, clarity, client effect
- Provide improvement steps
- Ask for their reflection
Top tip: praise publicly, correct privately, coach collaboratively
Learn how to delegate effectively
Delegation is not just about offloading tasks; it is a critical development tool. It allows others to build capability while giving you space to take on more strategic responsibilities.
Effective delegation involves:
- Choosing the right person for the task, based on skill level and development goals
- Being clear about expectations, deadlines, and quality standards
- Providing the context, don’t assume someone knows why the task matters
- Checking in at appropriate intervals without micromanaging
- Being available for support but not taking the work back
In tax work, where precision is essential, you may feel anxious about delegating. But with clear expectations and regular communication, delegation becomes far less risky than it seems.
Action to take: delegate properly
Goal: develop capability, not dependency
Before delegating:
- Choose task aligned with development level
- Explain why task matters
- Define success standard
- Set deadline and checkpoints
During:
- Schedule a mid-point check-in
- Ask questions instead of fixing
After:
- Review learning, not just result
- Never take the task back unless critical
Establish strong communication habits
Good communication is at the heart of leadership. People need clarity about priorities, deadlines, and responsibilities. They also need reassurance and context, especially when a project becomes challenging.
Consider adopting regular check-ins with your team, brief but structured discussions where you:
- Review workload
- Identify any risks or blockers
- Align on priorities
- Offer support where needed
By normalising open communication, you reduce the likelihood of hidden problems and lastminute surprises.
Action to take: create a structured communication rhythm
Goal: no surprises
Run weekly check-ins (15–30 min each)
Agenda:
- Workload review
- Risks/blockers
- Priority alignment
- Support needed
- Development discussion
Team level:
- Hold a short weekly team huddle
- Share deadlines and pressure points early
Understand individual needs and working styles
No two team members are the same. Some thrive on detailed guidance, while others prefer autonomy. Some enjoy client-facing work, while others are more comfortable working on compliance tasks. As a manager, part of your role is understanding these preferences and using them to motivate, stretch, and inspire.
You don’t need to be an expert in personality theory. Simple conversations can reveal what someone needs to perform at their best. Ask questions like:
- “How do you prefer to receive feedback?”
- “What kinds of tasks energise you?”
- “How do you like to approach deadlines?”
The more tailored your management approach, the more engaged and productive your team will be.
Action to take: manage individuals differently
Goal: tailored leadership
For each team member document:
- Motivation triggers
- Preferred feedback style
- Autonomy level
- Stress signals
Then adapt:
- High performer – autonomy + stretch work
- Developing staff – structure + frequent feedback
- Anxious staff – clarity + reassurance
Manage pressure without passing it down unnecessarily
Tax professionals operate in a high-pressure environment, but your team doesn’t need to feel every stress you experience. Your role is to filter and prioritise.
If deadlines shift or pressures increase, take a moment before communicating with your team. Provide clarity, not panic. Break down work into achievable steps. Identify where you can negotiate timelines, redistribute tasks, or escalate issues constructively.
A calm manager creates a calm team, and a calm team delivers better work.
Action to take: handle pressure professionally
Goal: filter stress, don’t transmit it
Before communicating urgent work:
- Clarify priorities yourself first
- Break tasks into steps
- Decide what can move
- Escalate early if needed
Communicate:
- Facts
- Plan
- Support
Avoid:
- Panic tone
- Late surprises
- Last-minute dumping
Develop your own support network
Being a new manager can feel isolating. You’re expected to support others, but you also need support yourself. Build relationships with peers, mentors, and more experienced managers.
Use them as sounding boards. Share challenges, ask questions, and learn from their experiences. Many organisations also offer leadership training tailored for new managers, take advantage of it. Learning to manage people is an ongoing process, not a onetime event.‑time event.
Actions to take in month one: build your manager support system
Goal: you need coaching too
- Identify a mentor or senior manager
- Schedule monthly learning conversation
- Discuss one real situation each time
- Attend leadership training if offered
- Keep a “lessons learned” log
Lead by example
As a manager in a technical field, your behaviour sets the tone for your team. Model the standards you expect from others: professionalism, curiosity, integrity, fairness, and respect.
When you demonstrate these behaviours consistently, your team is far more likely to follow. People tend to emulate what they experience, not what they are told.
Action to take daily: lead by example
Goal: culture follows behaviour
Model:
- Professionalism
- Calm under pressure
- Fairness
- Curiosity
- Respect in feedback
Rule: your team copies what you tolerate and what you demonstrate.
Celebrate progress, not just outcomes
Tax work can be relentless. Once one deadline is met, another quickly follows. It’s important to acknowledge effort and celebrate achievements, both big and small.
This could mean praising a junior team member for producing a well structured schedule, recognising someone for handling a tricky client query, or thanking the team for pulling together during a busy period. Recognition builds morale and reinforces positive behaviours.‑structured schedule, recognising someone for handling a tricky client query, or thanking the team for pulling together during a busy period. Recognition builds morale and reinforces positive behaviours.
Action to take: recognise effort consistently
Goal: maintain morale in deadline-heavy work
Every week:
- Thank at least one person individually
- Recognise one behaviour publicly
- Highlight improvement, not only perfection
Examples:
- Good client handling
- Clear workpaper structure
- Supporting teammates
Final thoughts
Your first people management role as a tax professional is a significant step in your career. While the shift from technical expert to leader can be challenging, it is also rewarding. You now can shape the careers of others, influence the way work is delivered, and contribute to a positive team culture.
Approach the role with curiosity, humility, and a willingness to grow. With the right mindset and habits, you will not only succeed as a manager, you will help your team thrive.
Like this article?
This article is a part of our Tax Trailblazers series. Want to read similar content, receive exclusive event invites and detailed salary information? Join our community today!
